Hey there, Comet!
With silent films, most of the action is in the expressions and behavior of the characters. If you have ever seen the movie "A Quiet Place", it is a great example of great acting and action (although it is not completely silent, but it still fits in the genre and is a great film).
Suspenseful films are the best kind of silent films. You could do one based on the perspective of a deaf character, and I'm fairly certain it would be great.
If you have any other ideas you want to run by me, I would be happy to help!
I am a director and screenwriter for short films (as a hobby. I am actually a graphic designer) and I would totally be willing to help you out if you needed it! I know a lot of useful information that you could use to make your film great and get a good grade.
Hope this helps!